Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

Court Overturns DOT Cut to New York Funds Over Non-Domiciled CDLs

A federal appeals court ruled DOT was wrong to withhold $73,502,543 from New York over non-domiciled CDL terms. What the ruling says and who it covers.

Young stylish female lawyer in formal clothes with name tag holding folders while going downstairs near stone building with columns
Photo: Sora Shimazaki / Pexels

A federal appeals court has ruled that the U.S. Department of Transportation acted unlawfully when it withheld part of New York’s federal transportation money over the way the state issues non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled unanimously on Friday, calling the funding denial “arbitrary and capricious,” FreightWaves reported.

The decision restores New York’s position in a dispute worth $73,502,543, the amount affected by the DOT’s action. It also weakens the federal argument in a similar case California is fighting.

What DOT and FMCSA objected to

A non-domiciled CDL is a commercial license issued to a driver who is not a U.S. citizen or permanent resident. In April, the DOT said it would deny New York about 4% of its normal federal funding. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, a defendant in the case New York brought, said the state was handing these licenses to noncitizens whose permission to stay in the country ran out before the license did. Under the rules the court described, a CDL could run five years after first issuance and eight years after renewal, the same terms that apply to domiciled licenses.

After reviewing New York’s practices in 2025, FMCSA concluded the state was “substantially noncompliant with federal regulations,” according to the court’s summary. The agency’s complaint centered on licenses that outlasted the holder’s legal stay. FMCSA argued that requiring the two dates to match was “not a new requirement” and that it was free to enforce it now even though it had focused on other parts of state CDL programs in earlier years.

Why the court sided with New York

New York argued that no federal law requires a non-domiciled CDL to expire before the driver’s authorized stay ends, and that the state could not violate a rule that did not exist. The panel agreed. The judges wrote that FMCSA itself conceded the federal regulations in effect at the time contained no “expiration-matching requirement.”

FMCSA also asked the court to look past a literal reading and accept its interpretation as common sense. The judges rejected that approach, saying the agency’s admission about the plain words of its own rule should settle the case. Reading the agency’s intent into the regulation, they said, had no support in the text.

The court traced the history back to a 2011 rule, which it said has no matching requirement. Before September 2025, the judges wrote, states did not have to tie non-domiciled CDL terms to the expiration dates on a driver’s lawful presence documents. They added that FMCSA could not point to any earlier case in which it had found a state noncompliant on this point.

What this means for drivers holding these licenses

The number of people in the dispute is large. According to the court, New York has about 32,600 non-domiciled CDL or commercial learner’s permit holders, roughly 7% of the licenses in the state.

To get one of these licenses, applicants had to pass the usual skills tests and show lawful presence documents in place of proof of citizenship or permanent residency. Accepted papers included an unexpired Employment Authorization Document, or a foreign passport with an approved I-94 form, the record the U.S. gives foreign visitors when they arrive legally.

The ruling covers the period before September 2025. Federal policy on these licenses has since changed, and our guide to who still qualifies under the non-domiciled CDL rule explains the current requirements.

California’s case is still pending

New York is not the only state in this fight. FreightWaves reported that California and the federal government have a similar case before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.

Source: FreightWaves