Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

Second Circuit Blocks FMCSA From Withholding $73 Million From New York Over CDLs

An appeals court ruled FMCSA could not hold back $73 million from New York over non-domiciled CDLs. The ruling and California's pending case.

Bride and groom share a tender moment on majestic courthouse steps. Elegant wedding attire.
Photo: David Guerrero / Pexels

A federal appeals court has ruled that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) acted unlawfully when it withheld $73 million in federal funding from New York over how the state issues non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses. A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit issued the opinion on Friday, Nov. 13, Land Line reported.

The panel called the agency’s decision “arbitrary and capricious,” a standard courts use to strike down agency actions. Because New York’s handling of these licenses was the only basis for the funding decision, that decision cannot stand, the court said.

What the dispute was about

The case centers on non-domiciled CDLs held by drivers with U.S. work authorization. FMCSA audited these licenses and found that 30 states were issuing them for periods that ran past the date the driver’s work authorization expired.

According to the agency, every one of those states except New York and California worked with FMCSA to fix the mismatch. FMCSA then withheld funding from the two holdouts, citing their lack of cooperation, and both states went to court.

At oral arguments on Sept. 28, New York’s attorney, Anthony Raduazo, argued that no federal statute, regulation or guidance document required a CDL to expire when the holder’s work authorization does. He said it was the first time in the 40-year history of New York’s CDL program that the state had been found in substantial non-compliance.

Simon Jerome, arguing for the U.S. Department of Transportation, said the regulation’s context and its use of the word “unexpired” meant a driver’s lawful presence should cover the full life of the license. He also pointed out that only New York and California had refused to work with the agency.

What the court decided

Judge Alison J. Nathan, writing for the panel, said FMCSA was free to adopt new rules on non-domiciled CDLs through formal rulemaking, and later did so. What the agency could not do was cut funding over a requirement that did not yet exist. The court found that states had no obligation to match CDL terms to work authorization dates before September 2025.

Nathan also wrote that FMCSA had not identified any earlier case in which it found a state out of compliance on this point. That record of never enforcing the requirement weakened the agency’s argument that it had been built into the rules all along, the opinion said.

What it means for drivers and carriers

The ruling deals with the funding decision against New York. The court noted separately that FMCSA later went through rulemaking to set new requirements for non-domiciled CDLs, and the opinion treats that as a step the agency was entitled to take. For New York, the decision means the agency’s basis for withholding the $73 million has been rejected.

California’s case is still pending

A similar fight over $160 million that FMCSA withheld from California is before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. That court heard oral arguments on Sept. 11, and a ruling is expected soon, according to Land Line.

Source: Land Line