Court Voids FMCSA’s $73.5 Million Penalty Over New York CDLs
A federal appeals court set aside FMCSA's $73.5 million funding penalty against New York over non-domiciled CDLs. Newer rules still apply.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on Nov. 13 set aside an FMCSA determination that withheld $73,502,543 in federal highway money from New York. The ruling covers how the state issued non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses under rules in place before September 2025. It does not decide whether the newer federal rules are lawful, and those rules still apply to new licensing transactions.
According to Tank Transport, which reported on the decision, a New York credential does not give a driver clearance to work or lose it because of this ruling. The case is about the state’s funding, not any individual license.
Why the funding penalty fell
FMCSA announced the penalty on April 16. The agency said New York had not revoked non-domiciled commercial learner’s permits and CDLs that it considered improperly issued. Its main objection was licenses that ran past the expiration dates on the holders’ immigration documents.
The amount was 4% of the state’s National Highway Performance Program and Surface Transportation Block Grant Program funds, and it applied to fiscal year 2027. New York challenged the determination on April 24. The state argued the agency was applying a new reading of long-standing requirements.
The court agreed on the text of the old rules. They required applicants to show specified unexpired documents, but they did not require states to make a CDL’s expiration date match those documents. The majority also pointed to the structure and history of the regulations. Matching expiration dates was the only basis for the determination, so the court set it aside. Judge Schwartz concurred in the result in a separate opinion and would have decided the case on the regulatory text alone.
The newer non-domiciled CDL rules are untouched
The court said outright that it was not ruling on whether the newer regulations are lawful. Separate litigation covers them. FMCSA’s final rule from February 2026, effective March 16, sets an explicit expiration limit. For an applicant domiciled in a foreign jurisdiction, the credential cannot run past the I-94 or I-94A admit-until date or expiration date, or past one year, whichever comes first.
The same rule limits the qualifying employment-based immigration classifications for those applicants to H-2A, H-2B and E-2. State agencies must verify the status documents and handle issuance, transfer, renewal and upgrade transactions in person. The rule counts reinstatement and replacement documents as issuance.
FMCSA’s current FAQs separate two situations. Updating medical-certification information is one. Reinstating commercial driving privileges after a downgrade is another, and it triggers the newer eligibility checks. On May 5, the D.C. Circuit denied requests to stay the February rule while letting the challenge go forward. That was a ruling on temporary relief, not on the merits.
Why it matters for tank fleets and drivers
A driver who holds a license today is not guaranteed eligibility for the next renewal or replacement. Fleets that employ drivers with New York credentials need to know each driver’s current status, endorsements and next licensing transaction.
As of Nov. 17, the New York DMV’s CDL application page still said its offices were temporarily unable to accept CLP or CDL document applications from people who are neither U.S. citizens nor lawful permanent residents. That notice concerns processing of applications. It does not settle the status of licenses already issued.
For interstate operations under 49 CFR Part 391, a carrier must still use drivers who meet the qualification rules: physical qualification, English-language proficiency, a valid license and no disqualification. Under 49 CFR 383.93, tank-vehicle and hazardous-materials endorsements remain required where the vehicle and cargo call for them. Drivers also still have to tell their employers about licensing actions. Tank Transport noted that this employer-notification duty continues even though a federal reporting requirement directed to the driver’s home state was removed.
What to check now
- The driver’s current state driving record and any suspension or downgrade notice.
- The next licensing transaction the driver needs, and the state agency’s current instructions for it.
- Whether the tank-vehicle and hazardous-materials endorsements required for the assigned load are in place.
Carriers arranging a renewal, transfer or reinstatement should confirm the state’s instructions before building a dispatch plan around finishing it.
Source: Tank Transport


