Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

California, FMCSA Clash in Court Over 20,000 Non-Domiciled CDLs

A federal appeals court heard California's challenge to the FMCSA pause on non-domiciled CDLs. What each side argued and a related case next week.

The majestic facade of the United States Supreme Court under a clear blue sky.
Photo: Mark Stebnicki / Pexels

California and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration argued on Friday before a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia over the agency’s pause on new non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses in the state. FreightWaves reported that the case, California Department of Motor Vehicles vs. U.S. Department of Transportation, also involves transportation funding the federal government withheld from California over the same dispute.

In its brief, FMCSA said that roughly 20,000 of the 65,000 non-domiciled CDLs the California DMV issued, nearly one-third, were improper because the license ran past the date the driver was legally allowed to stay in the U.S. Most people who hold non-domiciled CDLs are immigrants, so the outcome reaches a large group of working drivers.

What the pause covers

FMCSA ordered the pause after the agency and the state failed to settle the problems found in a federal audit of California’s CDL program. The pause stops the DMV from issuing new non-domiciled CDLs and from renewing existing ones. It does not decertify the state’s entire CDL program, which would affect every commercial license California has issued. Kristen Kido, the California deputy attorney general who argued for the DMV, made that point to the judges while still describing the pause’s effects as extreme.

The judges spent most of the hearing on narrow questions: whether California cooperated with the audit, and whether FMCSA had the legal authority to impose the pause. The funding cutoff came up little during oral arguments.

California’s argument: no rule ties a CDL to immigration papers

The state says federal law does not require a CDL to expire on or before the date on a driver’s lawful presence documents. Its brief said FMCSA pointed to no federal rule that sets such a limit and instead read one into the requirement that states accept only unexpired lawful presence documents. The DMV also argued that FMCSA reads the statutes too broadly.

Kido told the court the agency lacks the power to impose an open-ended pause before any enforcement action, especially one that also blocks the DMV from correcting or renewing valid, unexpired licenses. She said California did cancel numerous non-domiciled CDLs after the audit, which she called “substantial compliance with all of the relevant components of federal law.” If those cancellations missed a deadline, she argued, a slip in the corrective schedule cannot on its own justify a finding of noncompliance.

FMCSA’s argument: timing and responsiveness

Simon Jerome, the Justice Department attorney representing FMCSA, told the panel it made little sense for a license to be valid for five or eight years when the immigration document behind it could expire the next day. He said that issue sits at the center of California’s case.

Jerome also told the court that timing and responsiveness are the heart of the dispute. “Should FMCSA have given the DMV more time?” he asked. He and Judge Cornelia Pillard discussed a letter the DMV sent to FMCSA on Christmas Eve, and whether the holiday slowed the state’s reply. The federal brief called the resulting violations of federal and California law undisputed.

What’s at stake for drivers and carriers

As long as the pause stands, non-domiciled drivers in California cannot get a new CDL from the state or renew the one they have. Carriers that employ these drivers face the same limit. The panel’s ruling will also show how far FMCSA can go against a state it says did not fix audit findings fast enough. The federal government is still withholding some highway funding from California while the dispute continues.

The rules for these licenses have tightened since the audit. Our guide to who still qualifies under the non-domiciled CDL rule covers the current standard.

Another case next week

The same court will hear oral arguments on Wednesday in Lujan vs. FMCSA. That case raises other issues too, but it also asks whether a non-domiciled CDL can last longer than the holder’s legal permission to stay in the country, and it covers FMCSA’s tighter limits on who can get one.

Separately, the Raleigh News & Observer reported that the Department of Transportation cleared North Carolina to resume issuing non-domiciled CDLs after the state made several changes. FMCSA has since made it much harder for non-domiciled applicants to qualify.

Source: yahoo.com