Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

J.B. Hunt Must Face Negligent Hiring Claim Over Fatal 2023 Crash

An Arizona federal judge cut one claim against J.B. Hunt's brokerage but let negligent hiring go forward in a fatal 2023 crash case, FreightWaves reports.

A federal judge in Arizona on Thursday granted J.B. Hunt’s brokerage arm one of two requests for summary judgment in a fatal crash lawsuit and denied the other, so a negligent hiring claim against the company will proceed, FreightWaves reported.

The case, Crystal Gee et al. vs. J.B. Hunt et al., is shaping up as a closely watched test of broker liability after the decision in Montgomery vs. Caribe Transport II.

The crash and the lawsuit

The crash happened in October 2023 on U.S. Route 160, a two-lane highway. According to the recap by Judge Stephen McNamee of the U.S. District Court for Arizona, a truck driven by an employee of the carrier Borderlanders Inc. crossed into the oncoming lane and did not promptly return. A car coming the other way, carrying a couple and their three children, hit the truck head-on. The two adults were killed and the three children were seriously injured. Gee is the guardian of the children. The plaintiffs filed suit in March 2024.

The load belonged to medical equipment supplier Lincare, which had hired J.B. Hunt’s brokerage to move it from Denver to Phoenix. The price was $1,350. Borderlanders booked it through J.B. Hunt’s online broker platform.

What J.B. Hunt won and lost

J.B. Hunt asked the court to dismiss two claims. The first was that it was vicariously liable, meaning responsible for the driver’s actions as a statutory employee. The court agreed with J.B. Hunt. The company argued the federal leasing regulations did not apply because it never leased equipment to Borderlanders, and the judge wrote that it is undisputed Borderlanders hauled the load under its own authority with its own equipment and driver. Those regulations apply only if there is a valid lease, according to the decision.

The second request targeted the claim that J.B. Hunt was negligent in choosing Borderlanders. The judge denied it, finding that a rational jury could conclude J.B. Hunt knew or should have known of the safety risks. He wrote that the plaintiffs cited evidence that J.B. Hunt never reviewed Borderlanders’ public crash history, FMCSA safety scores, safety assessment alerts or inspection violations before selecting it.

J.B. Hunt argued that no underlying tort claim remains against Borderlanders, which settled with the plaintiffs. A separate action against the driver was dismissed voluntarily with prejudice. The judge found factual disputes remain on the hiring claim. J.B. Hunt (NASDAQ: JBHT) declined to comment, citing the ongoing litigation.

An outside lawyer’s view

Gregory Reed, a partner at Hanson Bridgett who leads its transportation practice, told FreightWaves that J.B. Hunt’s arguments were “common refrains in the broker and logistics industry” but called them unavailing. He summarized two of them: that Borderlanders was an FMCSA-authorized, though unrated, carrier, so brokers should be shielded from negligence claims for using it; and that its safety record was too thin to put J.B. Hunt on notice, given how few bad incidents it had compared with its drivers and loads.

Reed said both arguments go to the duty of care and what a company should have known, and that their failure at this stage suggests courts may be unlikely to take such cases away from juries.

Why it matters for brokers and carriers

J.B. Hunt’s original defense relied on the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (F4A), which bars state action affecting a price, route or service. The company argued the law’s safety exception did not cover brokers. FreightWaves says that defense ended with the Montgomery ruling.

Industry officials have argued since Montgomery that brokers lack guidance on what vetting protects them from negligent hiring claims. FreightWaves pointed to a Texas verdict of more than $600 million against C.H. Robinson over a 2021 wreck that killed three people, even though the carrier it hired had a Satisfactory FMCSA rating. The vetting question looks different here, according to the report, because briefs in the case describe Borderlanders as lacking a stellar safety record. A jury may be the next step.

Source: FreightWaves