FMCSA Crash Preventability Program: Which Crashes Qualify
Carriers can ask FMCSA to review a crash in DataQs and have it marked not preventable. See which crashes qualify and how to submit a request.
The FMCSA Crash Preventability Determination Program lets motor carriers and drivers ask the agency to review a DOT-recordable crash and decide whether the carrier could have prevented it. Crashes in a set list of categories, such as being rear-ended or hit while legally parked, can be marked “Not Preventable.” The request goes through FMCSA’s DataQs system with a police report and supporting evidence.
What does a preventability determination do?
A determination is FMCSA’s finding on whether the commercial vehicle driver did or did not have a reasonable chance to avoid the crash. When FMCSA decides a crash was not preventable, the finding is shown next to that crash in the carrier’s safety record, and the crash is left out of the carrier’s Crash Indicator BASIC calculation in the Safety Measurement System. The crash itself stays in the record.
That matters because the Crash Indicator feeds the percentile that insurers, brokers, shippers and enforcement staff see. A single crash that was not your fault can count against you until it is reviewed.
Which crashes can be reviewed?
Only DOT-recordable crashes are eligible. Under FMCSA’s rules a recordable crash involves a death, an injury that needs treatment away from the scene, or a vehicle towed because of disabling damage.
The program works from a list of crash types where the other party, not the truck driver, is usually the cause. The categories include:
- The commercial vehicle was struck in the rear.
- The commercial vehicle was legally stopped or parked when it was hit.
- The driver of the other vehicle was impaired by alcohol or drugs.
- The other vehicle was traveling the wrong way on a divided road.
- The commercial vehicle was struck by debris or cargo from another vehicle.
- The crash involved an animal strike.
FMCSA has revised the eligible categories since the program began and may do so again, so read the current list on its program page before filing. A crash outside the list can still be questioned through a regular DataQs challenge, but it will not be handled as a preventability review.
How do I submit a request?
- Confirm the crash appears on your record and fits an eligible category.
- Gather the police report first. It is the document FMCSA relies on most, and a report that names the other driver’s violation is strong evidence.
- Collect photos of the scene and the vehicles, dash camera or other video, witness statements, and any citation issued to the other driver.
- Log in to DataQs, choose a request for the crash and select the crash preventability determination request type.
- Describe in plain words what happened, in order, and attach every file. Say which eligible category applies and point to the line in the police report that supports it.
- Submit it and watch the DataQs status. FMCSA may ask for more documents.
Both the carrier and the driver involved can file. File within the window FMCSA sets for these requests, which is measured from the crash date, and do not wait until a crash is dragging down a rating or an audit is scheduled.
What evidence helps most?
Evidence that shows who did what and when. A complete police report, a citation to the other driver, video showing the other vehicle’s movement, and witness statements that agree with each other carry the most weight. Vehicle data such as speed and braking records can support your account if the system recorded it. If a device problem affects your electronic records, see the FMCSA notice on 133 ELDs pulled from the approved list for how replacement deadlines were handled.
Avoid vague claims. A statement that the other driver “came out of nowhere” with nothing behind it rarely changes a decision. For fraud cases, where a crash may have been staged to claim damages, the facts and legal risks are different, as the Louisiana staged-crash cases show, and a lawyer should be involved.
What results can I get?
FMCSA reviews the file and issues one of three outcomes: preventable, not preventable, or undecided. “Not Preventable” removes the crash from the Crash Indicator calculation. “Preventable” leaves it in. “Undecided” means the evidence did not allow a finding, and the crash is treated as it was before the review. If you disagree with a decision, you can ask for a further review through DataQs and supply new evidence.
Programs and portals change, so confirm the steps on the FMCSA site and file through DataQs itself.
Quick answers
Does a not preventable finding delete the crash?
No. The crash stays on the record with the determination attached. It is only excluded from the Crash Indicator calculation.
Who can submit a request?
The motor carrier or the driver involved in the crash can file through DataQs. Carriers usually file because the crash sits on their safety record.
Can I ask for a review if the crash was partly my fault?
You can file, but only crashes that fit an eligible category are reviewed under this program, and the evidence still has to show the crash could not reasonably have been avoided.
Do I need a lawyer?
Not for an ordinary request. Many carriers file on their own with a police report and photos. If injuries, a lawsuit or suspected fraud are involved, talk to an attorney before sending statements to FMCSA.



