J.B. Hunt Agrees to Pay $3.18 Million Over Worker Tobacco Surcharge
J.B. Hunt will pay $3.18 million to settle an employee lawsuit over a $15 weekly tobacco surcharge on health insurance. What the suit claimed and what comes next.

J.B. Hunt Transport Services has agreed to pay $3.18 million to settle a proposed class action from employees who say the carrier overcharged tobacco users for health insurance, Hoodline reported, citing court documents. The workers objected to a $15 weekly surcharge added to their premiums under the company’s employee benefits plan.
The deal still needs a judge’s approval. J.B. Hunt filed an unopposed motion for preliminary approval of the settlement on Nov. 10.
What the J.B. Hunt workers alleged
Michael Barker and George Cross filed the suit in June in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Arkansas, Fayetteville Division, according to court documents cited by the Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette. They sued for themselves and other employees who paid the tobacco surcharge under the J.B. Hunt Transport Inc. Employee Benefits Plan.
The complaint said the plan charged the $15-per-week fee without offering a reasonable alternative standard that met federal rules. In practice, that usually means a way for tobacco users to avoid the fee, such as a cessation program. The suit also said plan materials that discussed the surcharge lacked the required notice about that alternative.
The two sides settled in mediation before the court decided whether the case could proceed as a class action. Filings in mid-September recorded the agreement. Law360 also reported the deal and put the figure at roughly $3.2 million, which matches the $3.18 million in the court filings.
The federal rule behind tobacco surcharge suits
Federal wellness-program rules for group health plans, at 29 CFR 2590.702, treat a penalty such as a surcharge the same way they treat a reward. That is the language these lawsuits lean on when they argue that a tobacco fee has to come with a compliant way out.
The Lowell, Arkansas, carrier is one of many large employers facing similar claims. Insurance Business has reported different totals for the wave of ERISA class actions over tobacco surcharges: one report counted more than 50 similar cases in federal courts nationwide, and another described more than 80. Both said more than 30 were filed in 2026.
Mondelez International is another employer named in these suits, according to Insurance Business. In Mehlberg v. Compass Group USA, a judge found that Compass Group violated ERISA by not retroactively refunding a $1,248-per-year tobacco penalty to employees who finished a cessation program, the outlet reported.
A Health Affairs study found that in states allowing tobacco surcharges, 10.8 percent of employers broke Affordable Care Act rules by charging tobacco users higher premiums without offering a cessation program.
What it means for J.B. Hunt employees
Current and former J.B. Hunt workers who paid the tobacco surcharge under the company plan are the people covered by the settlement. Court filings so far have not said how much each person could receive or how the settlement fund would be run.
The next step is the court’s ruling on preliminary approval. Drivers and other employees who paid the fee should watch for a settlement notice that explains who qualifies and how payments will work.
Source: Hoodline



