C.R. Bard Loses Bid for New Trial in $70 Million Driver Case
A truck driver's $70 million verdict against C.R. Bard survives appeal, but a partial retrial could cut the punitive part to $250,000.

C.R. Bard has failed to get a $70 million verdict thrown out and the case retried from scratch. According to CDLLife, an appeal seeking that outcome was rejected, so the award to truck driver Gary Walker stands in part and the case goes back for a partial retrial.
Walker will receive $20 million in compensatory damages whatever the retrial decides. The $50 million in punitive damages is what remains in question.
What the driver says happened
Walker worked as a truck driver from 1970 to 1999, hauling sterilized medical products in and around Covington, Georgia. He also lived within two miles of the same facility from 1991 to 2017. In 2017, he was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma, a cancer of the lymphatic system.
He sued Bard, which used ethylene oxide to sterilize medical equipment at the plant. His suit alleges that the company did not start controlling emissions of the chemical until 1990, although the facility opened in 1967. The company reportedly received a warning in 1980 from the chemical’s manufacturer connecting exposure to cancer.
Six other people who lived near the plant and were later diagnosed with cancer testified at Walker’s trial.
The verdict and the appeal
The jury awarded Walker $70 million, made up of $20 million in compensatory damages, which cover a plaintiff’s losses, and $50 million in punitive damages, which are meant to punish the defendant. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported that Bard was held liable for negligence and for creating a public nuisance.
Bard denies wrongdoing. It asked to overturn the verdict and retry the whole case, and that request was rejected.
What the partial retrial will decide
Instead of a full retrial, a jury will take up one narrow question: whether the company acted with specific intent to cause harm. If the jury does not find that intent, Walker’s punitive damages will be capped at $250,000.
The negligence and public nuisance findings are not part of that question. The retrial concerns only the company’s intent and the punitive portion of the award.
What this means for the money at stake
The outcome of the retrial sets the size of the final award. At the low end, Walker’s total would be the $20 million in compensatory damages plus no more than $250,000 in punitive damages. The original punitive figure was $50 million.
The case connects a driver’s job to chemical exposure in two ways. Walker hauled products from the plant for nearly three decades, according to the dates reported, and he also lived close to it for years. His claim names both periods, along with the company’s emissions history.
Bard, for its part, maintains that it did nothing wrong. The appeal it filed was its attempt to wipe out the entire verdict, and the court’s decision leaves the compensatory award in place regardless.
Source: CDLLife



