Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

Analysts: Fewer Drivers, Not Demand, Are Lifting Truckload Rates

Transport Topics analysts say a supply-driven recovery lifted freight rates in Q3 as about 70,000 drivers left the market. Costs and weak retail freight remain.

Wide view of a highway in Warsaw with vehicles under a clear sky.
Photo: Aleksander Dumała / Pexels

Freight rates strengthened in the third quarter because capacity tightened and costs rose, not because demand improved, analysts told Transport Topics. They describe a supply-driven recovery that followed a long freight downcycle, which began with the coronavirus pandemic and left the industry with too many trucks for several years.

This year a federal crackdown on noncompliant drivers, along with other market pressures, has removed capacity. Carriers are now pushing for higher rates even though demand is soft.

About 70,000 drivers have left the market

Ken Hoexter, a managing director at Bank of America, said the recovery comes from the supply side. By his estimate, around 70,000 drivers have been taken out of a pool of a million and a half. Some of his investors worry that the peak of capacity cuts has passed. He expects the pressure on capacity to continue, though he said the pace is unclear, and investors are also unsure when freight demand will improve.

Bascome Majors, a managing director of transportation equity research at Stephens, said his team ended earnings season with the same view it started with: this is a supply-side recovery for truckload. He expects contract rates to keep rising along with driver pay and other costs that follow inflation. His team sees intermodal as the best positioned to grow, as shippers keep moving truckload freight to lower-cost options.

Enforcement and broker scrutiny shaped the market

Dan Moore, a senior transportation analyst at R.W. Baird, said increased enforcement by the Department of Transportation played a major role. Brokers also face more scrutiny over how they pick carriers after the Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II ruling by the Supreme Court. Moore said these factors created a constructive backdrop for the second quarter, which also included some freight pulled forward.

Seasonality weakened in July and August, Moore said, but base rates kept improving and spot rates began to turn up in August. Hoexter said rates peaked in the summer and that spot rates have come down since. They remain well above where they have been in recent years.

Weak consumer freight, stronger industrial demand

Moore said a weak consumer market, a lackluster housing market, auto sales, interest rates and fuel costs keep the freight economy from being robust. He finds it easier to see strength in the industrial economy, citing tailwinds from the One Big Beautiful Bill, the AI buildout and early signs of an oil field-services recovery.

Jason Seidl, a managing director at TD Cowen, said energy prices stayed high for longer than expected, but the consumer base held up. He said UPS and Knight-Swift Transportation Holdings expect a normal peak shipping season. Seidl also said the industrial economy showed broad strength in the quarter, with focus on hyperscalers, semiconductors and healthcare. He has heard concern about the data center buildout but suspects pushback is more a state-by-state matter.

What this means for carriers

Hoexter said many carriers have responded to the rebound by trying to increase utilization, while driver pay starts to scale up and operating costs rise across the truckload sector. Carriers that can price higher are benefiting, but they are also paying more for drivers.

Source: Transport Topics