Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

E3 CEO Tells Brokers to Strip Fines From Rate Confirmations

Freight brokers should audit rate confirmations and verify pickups, E3 Group's CEO said at a FreightWaves symposium on driver communication risk.

Chicken transport trucks at market in Chattanooga, TN.
Photo: K / Pexels

Freight brokers should audit what appears on their rate confirmations and keep driver contact to a minimum job, Aqil Naeem, co-founder and CEO of E3 Group, said at the FreightWaves Brokerage Compliance Symposium at F3. In what FreightWaves describes as a post-Montgomery liability environment, a late load or a casual text to a driver can become evidence in court.

Naeem said chief legal officers at brokers in the top 20 that E3 works with raised the question with him: how to talk to drivers without producing a lawsuit when one slip could carry exposure in the hundreds of millions.

Where courts draw the line

According to Naeem, routine check-ins are not what courts look at. They examine whether a broker exercised agency over the driver, meaning whether its language shaped what the driver did. He said mentioning a $10,000 or $15,000 fine to a driver can count as that kind of control, even when the fine is real.

He also cited a case in which a broker was held liable for not checking that its carrier had not double brokered the freight. The broker had skipped a simple check that the person picking up the load was who they should have been.

Two camps among brokers

Naeem sees brokers split. Some want little or no contact with drivers, and some E3 customers have asked to hide data in the verification product to limit what they can see. Others write SOPs (standard operating procedures) of about 20 questions, so every driver contact becomes a health and safety checklist.

Neither approach settles hard cases. If a driver reports being sick, the broker escalates to the dispatcher, and the dispatcher fails to replace the driver, a court could ask whether the broker should have found another carrier with eight hours of lead time. Naeem said court opinions tend to run against brokers, who look like large companies with deep pockets. He added that no right answer exists, only awareness of the risks.

A driver who says they are low on hours or too tired forces a similar choice. Asking about a backup driver can read as pressure to keep driving, while resetting the appointment means absorbing the customer’s reaction. Naeem said the right call may differ by customer, since some have stricter delivery requirements.

First fix: the rate confirmation

Naeem described cases where brokers were sued after shippers added fines to the rate confirmation and the broker passed that document to the driver. The argument was that passing on the penalty pressured the driver to arrive on time. His first step is auditing everything on the document and removing language that could prompt adverse behavior. The second is defining what happens after pickup, including how late loads are documented and how exceptions are escalated.

Automation, recordings and records

Naeem expects the most advanced brokers to move toward automated communication governed by a documented SOP. Before pickup, he advises automating standard checks, above all confirming that the person arriving at the dock works for the assigned carrier. By his estimate about a third of the brokers he talks with do not do that, and those who do it manually open themselves to more liability. After pickup, if the load is on time, he suggests leaving communication automated and escalating to a human only when the driver replies that something is wrong.

On call recording, he has seen brokers record every call and others record none. He cautioned against recording selectively, saying that not recording carrier conversations also looks bad in court.

For personally identifiable information, he advised destroying it immediately. He said he has met top 50 brokers with tens of thousands of driver CDLs sitting in email. E3 stores hashes of driver identities instead of documents. About 7,000 drivers are verified per day and more than half a million owner-operators have been seen, Naeem said.

What it means for shippers and brokers

Naeem expects liability exposure to move up the supply chain. He pointed to the Unilever lawsuit, where no one checked that the truck arriving at the facility belonged to the intended carrier, and the shipper became a defendant. Shippers are now asking which brokers have verification and communication controls, and Naeem called it an opportunity for brokers that act early.

Source: FreightWaves