Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21 Updated

Trucking and freight news for drivers, carriers and shippers.

TQL Seeks Dismissal of Carriers’ RICO Suit Over Illegal Carriers

TQL has filed two motions to dismiss a civil RICO suit by motor carriers. What it alleges, the $150 million exposure and why a lawyer doubts it survives.

Total Quality Logistics has filed two motions to dismiss a civil racketeering lawsuit brought by motor carriers who accuse it and C.H. Robinson of working with illegal trucking companies to push down rates. The carriers say the scheme cost them tens of millions of dollars in lost shipper contracts, according to FreightWaves.

The case is still in the pleading phase, with a tentative jury selection date of April 2028. Matt Leffler, an attorney who discussed the suit with FreightWaves, said that date could slip further and that the plaintiffs face long odds.

What the carriers allege against TQL and C.H. Robinson

The suit is filed under RICO, the federal racketeering law, which also allows private civil claims. The plaintiffs claim the two brokers relied on fraudulent carriers that used forced labor and manipulated electronic logging devices (ELDs, the units that record a driver’s hours). Legitimate carriers, they argue, were shut out of shipper contracts as a result.

FreightWaves describes the plaintiffs as six carriers but lists seven company names: Stevens Trucking, Western Flyer Express, D&M Carriers, Frey Miller Trucking, IWX Motor Freight, Christensen Transportation and EOS Incorporated.

Civil RICO triples any damages a jury awards. Using an example from the interview, a $50 million damages finding would expose the defendants to $150 million, plus attorney’s fees.

TQL’s two motions and the fight over venue

TQL’s first motion argues the complaint fails to state a claim. The second asks to move the case from Texas to federal court in Ohio, TQL’s home state, on forum non conveniens grounds, a doctrine that lets a court send a case to a more suitable location. TQL says the relevant evidence is in Ohio and that its arbitration clauses and other contracts are better handled there. Because RICO is a federal statute, the case stays in federal court whichever venue wins.

C.H. Robinson entered its appearance in the case the day before the interview. Its response is expected within one to two weeks.

Why it matters for brokers and carriers

Leffler said brokers now handle 30% of all freight in the United States, a share that has cut into the volumes motor carriers haul directly. If the claims survive dismissal, he said, any broker could face similar suits on the theory that vetting carriers through FMCSA processes and third-party technology does not protect it from racketeering claims.

He sees weak points in the plaintiffs’ case. Three of the six carriers have out-of-service rates for their commercial vehicles above the national average of 24.9%, which could undercut their claim that broker misconduct cost them business. He also cited the Supreme Court’s 2006 Anza decision, in which the court held that lost business contracts tied to alleged fraud cannot be recovered under civil RICO.

“I think that the plaintiffs have a really hard road ahead of them,” Leffler said. He expects the case to be dismissed before it reaches discovery, the stage where both sides exchange evidence. He also suggested the plaintiffs may care less about winning than about media attention that pressures others to make changes.

What happens next

The court is expected to hear arguments on TQL’s motions soon. Leffler said the pleading phase could be resolved within the next month or two, with C.H. Robinson’s response due in the coming weeks.

Source: FreightWaves