Truckload Rejections Double to 12.8% Yet Freight Market Stays Soft
Truckload tender rejections are near 12.8%, about twice last year's level, but peak season pressure is missing. Reefer rejections are at 21%.

Carriers are turning down about 12.8% of truckload tenders, roughly twice the 6% seen at this point last year, yet the market lacks the tightening that usually comes before peak season. That is the assessment of FreightWaves analysts Julie Van de Kamp and Craig Fuller. A tender is a load offer from a shipper or broker, and a rejection means the carrier declined it. Higher rejections normally mean scarce trucks and firmer rates.
The analysts said the flat reading raises doubts about the strength of a holiday surge and about what 2027 contract rates will look like.
Little change in three weeks
The national rejection index has eased by only about 1 percentage point over the past 20 days. Van de Kamp said a bit more heat in the market would signal a strong 2027, and that it has not shown up yet.
Demand is the brighter spot. Fuller said the Outbound Tender Volume Index is averaging 11,434 in November. That is 12% above November a year ago and roughly 3% above October, which he called the first real demand build going into the holidays.
Reefer stands apart
Refrigerated freight is the tightest segment. Reefer tender rejections are at 21%, against 12.6% a year ago, which FreightWaves ties to Thanksgiving food shipments and shrinking capacity.
Van de Kamp also raised a super El Niño that some forecasters rank as the strongest in more than 100 years. She said it could squeeze reefer capacity further this winter, especially for protect-from-freeze loads of food and electronics. Those loads ride in temperature-controlled trailers so they stay above freezing.
Rates by equipment
Spot rates are splitting by trailer type. Reefer rates jumped in July and have stayed high. Flatbed holds a premium thanks to AI data center construction and industrial work. Dry van has mostly leveled off.
Fuller pointed to C.H. Robinson’s earnings commentary, which puts the 2026 flatbed cost-per-mile forecast at 28% and the 2027 figure at another 10%. The company also said early November usually brings some rate relief ahead of Thanksgiving, though this year it may be smaller than normal.
The Pacific Northwest is starting to tighten as apple, potato and Christmas tree harvests pick up. Van de Kamp said the region is “pretty much dead 9 months out of the year” before it turns sharply.
What it means for drivers and small carriers
Carriers with reefer equipment face the strongest demand for their trucks, while dry van operators see little change. Contract rates for next year are often influenced by how tight the market looks in the fall, so a rejection rate that is high but not rising leaves owner-operators and small fleets with a mixed signal.
What to watch next
Both analysts called the two weeks around Thanksgiving the clearest test of whether the market can build enough momentum for a tighter contract season. Winter weather is a further unknown for capacity, particularly in refrigerated.
Source: FreightWaves


