RICO Suit Against C.H. Robinson and TQL Heads Toward 2028 Jury
A proposed schedule sets jury selection for April 3, 2028 in the carriers' RICO suit against C.H. Robinson and TQL. TQL seeks dismissal over venue.

A proposed schedule in the carriers’ racketeering lawsuit against brokerage giants C.H. Robinson and TQL puts jury selection on April 3, 2028, about 17 months away, according to FreightWaves. The dates are not final. A scheduling conference is set for Nov. 23 in the case, which is before Judge Rodney Gilstrap in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas.
Before any trial, the court has to decide whether the case belongs in Texas at all. TQL has asked for a dismissal on venue grounds, and the carriers filed a response last week.
A proposed calendar that runs into 2028
The filing lays out several late 2027 dates for discovery, the phase in which each side gathers evidence. It also suggests a late January 2028 date for finishing mediation. Proposed jury instructions and other documents would be due March 13, 2028, and Judge Gilstrap would hold a pretrial conference on March 20 of that year.
The suit, Stevens Trucking et al. v. C.H. Robinson et al., was filed Sept. 23 under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act. The plaintiffs are Stevens Trucking, Western Flyer Express, D&M Carriers (doing business as Freymiller Trucking), Christenson Transportation, E.O.S. Inc. and IWX Motor Freight.
What TQL says about venue
TQL argues the case was filed in the wrong court under a doctrine called forum non conveniens. According to the company’s argument, every carrier in the suit except IWX signed a service contract that requires disputes to be heard in a state court in Clermont, Ohio, near TQL’s home city of Cincinnati.
C.H. Robinson has not filed anything in the case. A company spokeswoman said it has no connection to TQL’s venue request.
What the carriers allege
The carriers say the Ohio clause applies only if a court stretches it to cover "any dispute" at all, including matters unrelated to the contract. They argue the Texas court is the right place.
In a summary filing called an omnibus response, the carriers repeat their core allegation: the two large brokers undercut carrier rates through illegal carriers and what the suit calls forced labor. The original complaint does not define the term, but says the brokers choose foreign labor because it is easy to exploit. The carriers say this kept them from bidding meaningfully for shipper business and cost them agreements with shippers. These are allegations, and neither broker has had a ruling against it.
The carriers also claim the brokers helped drive the story of a truck driver shortage. They say there was none and that the defendants did not want to pay a living wage. The suit says C.H. Robinson promoted immigration to ease any shortage and that the American Trucking Associations lobbied the Department of Transportation in 2021 to loosen licensing and immigration rules.
The ATA’s response
The ATA is not a defendant. Henry Hanscom, its chief advocacy and public affairs officer, told FreightWaves that the group is not a party, that neither C.H. Robinson nor TQL is a member, and that the claims about the association are false.
What this means for brokers and carriers
FreightWaves reports that anyone in brokerage waiting for a broad precedent from the case faces a long wait. The venue dispute is the most pressing legal issue, and its outcome will decide whether the case proceeds in Texas on the schedule now proposed.
Source: FreightWaves


